Battle of the liquid pen eyeliners

best eyelinersI love black eyeliner. It should be a staple in anyone’s makeup bag. Over the years, I’ve used pencil, liquid, liquid pen, cream and gel liners. Liquid pen liners are, without a doubt, the easiest to use, even for a novice.

Just because the concept is simple though, it doesn’t mean that every liquid pen eyeliner is easy to use. If the brush is too soft or too stiff, if there isn’t enough product coming out, or the color payoff isn’t too great- your eyeliner will not look as clean and crisp and you’d like it to. Let’s talk about few of my favorite, and not-so-favorite liquid pen eyeliners.

best pen eyeliners

best eyeliners

Best liquid pen eyeliners. From left to right: Stila All-Day Water Proof Liquid Eye Liner, Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen, Kat Von D Tattoo Liner, NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner, L’Oreal Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Maybelline Master Precise by EyeStudio

Stila All-Day Water Proof Liquid Eye Liner. This is my favorite liner of this kind, hands down. A jet-black color, waterproof formula and soft applicator, this literally glides on skin and allows for an easy and smooth application. Lasts all day, without smudging.

Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen. I love the Colorstay range from Revlon, but I’m not a huge fan of this liquid eye pen. The applicator is nice because it’s stiff which makes it easy to control, but the color isn’t very black; it’s more like faded black. I find that when using this liner I have to keep going over and over a single line in order to have a decent color payoff, since it comes out a bit faded. It also doesn’t last nearly as long as I’d expect it to and was a bit disappointed to find that it smudged easily as well.

Kat Von D Tattoo Liner. This is another favorite of mine. Love the deep, black color, the applicator and the staying power. I didn’t really get along with this liner at first, because I thought that it dried oddly quick and layering it or fixing a bit here and there was an issue, but the more I use it, the better it works. The tip of the applicator is really thin, which allows for a precise application.

NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner. I was so excited when I first got this NYC liner, just because I freaking love their original liquid liner. This liner is awful. I love the applicator, but the liner itself is awful, watery and pretty much a waste of money. I feel so horrible writing this because I love NYC, but I gotta be honest with you.

L’Oreal Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner. I  really like this slim eyeliner, but whenever I do use it, I have to use a different liquid liner for bringing out the wing. This is great to use on your lash line, the product payoff is nice when the brush is put to the side, but you won’t be able to create any precise looks with this one (like thin lines, small wing, etc.). The applicator simply does not dispense any product when the tip is pointed straight-on.

Maybelline Master Precise by EyeStudio. This one is a bit similar to L’Oreal’s Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner. It’s great for defining the lash line, the color is very black, highly pigmented, but it’s not great at creating thin and very precise lines.

longlasting eyeliners

This is after wiping my arm down with an eye makeup remover. From left to right: Stila All-Day Water Proof Liquid Eye Liner, Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen, Kat Von D Tattoo Liner, NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner, L’Oreal Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Maybelline Master Precise by EyeStudio. 

Tried any of these? Have other favorites? Let me know down below!


  • Reply
    Charline Has a Blog
    May 15, 2015 at 8:15 am

    I tried the Master Precise and the Super Slim liquid liners, the l’Oréal one is better than the Maybelline, I reckon :)

    Love, Charline | Charline Has a Blog

  • Reply
    Emmys Blog
    May 15, 2015 at 8:33 am

    The Stila one sounds perfect! x
    Emma | Emmys Blog

  • Reply
    May 15, 2015 at 10:35 am

    I’ve recently been trying to come away from liquid liners and begin using gel, but it’s just not the same! The Stila one here sounds sooo good and I will deffo be giving it a go :)

    Abby //

    • Reply
      May 16, 2015 at 12:28 pm

      I love gel too, but these are definitely a bit easier to use ;)

  • Reply
    May 15, 2015 at 12:08 pm

    nice liquid eye liners selection have there. I like the stilla liquid eyeliner because it’s water proof :)

    • Reply
      May 16, 2015 at 12:29 pm

      Thanks Jamie.

  • Reply
    May 15, 2015 at 12:39 pm

    I always use a gel liner but I love how easy pens look to use! The Stila one sounds really good x

    Josie’s Journal

    • Reply
      May 16, 2015 at 12:29 pm

      I love using gel too! Bobbi Brown’s gel liner is my favorite.

  • Reply
    Hayley Larue
    May 15, 2015 at 1:53 pm

    Those eyeliners look absolutely amazing! That fine point looks like it will give the PERFECT line! Also love that you showed how each one applies!

    • Reply
      May 16, 2015 at 12:30 pm

      Thanks Hayley!

  • Reply
    May 15, 2015 at 3:36 pm

    Gorgeous. xx

  • Reply
    May 15, 2015 at 7:48 pm

    Wonderful review, love the Kat von D Tattoo liner, too. ;-)
    Wish you a nice weekend, dear…

  • Reply
    May 15, 2015 at 9:17 pm

    Looks to me that the stilla one an the KAT VON D are the best. The others are disappointing, the one that I like using the Jordana’s felt tip. It works great as well plus its a great price range. This was an amazing post !

  • Reply
    May 16, 2015 at 6:29 am

    This is such a great post for a lover of winged liner like me haha. I only have the Kat Von D from here but the Stila sounds great and I think I will try that next after this one runs out! xx

    Magpie Jasmine

  • Reply
    helen at thelovecatsinc
    May 16, 2015 at 11:54 am

    the stila one is my most repurchased! i got the kat von d one, but i thought it wasn’t as good. loving the soap and glory one at the moment though

    from helen at

    ps. win USA beauty goodies from lorac, tarte etc on my blog! click here.

  • Reply
    Natalie Heather
    May 16, 2015 at 6:07 pm

    I love this post! I think the stila liner is definitely the winner. I’ve never tried the black shade, but I tried the blue and really loved it. The KVD one also looks good!
    Ivory Avenue

  • Reply
    May 17, 2015 at 8:14 am

    I wonder if your NYC one is a dud, mine is super black and the formula is what I love about it!


  • Reply
    Brenda BusyBee
    May 18, 2015 at 6:33 am

    I haven’t tried any of these ones but the Stila one and the Kat Von D sound fab! I love the Charlotte Tilbury and the NYX curve eyeliner at the moment :) x

    Brenda BusyBee

  • Reply
    Nadia @ The View Is Beautiful
    May 19, 2015 at 12:01 pm

    The Stila liquid liner is my holy grail black liner! It’s easy to use lasts on the eye and the pen doesn’t dry out super quickly like so many others I’ve tried. I will say though I bought the dark brown version and it didn’t seem like it was the same great formula. If you have any brown liquid liner suggestions I’d love to hear them!

  • Reply
    ☆caroline☆ (@quarolynee)
    May 28, 2015 at 11:54 am

    I love stila stay all day, seriously if one day they decide to take it away from me I will cry… I also tried the Kat Von D one but I had quite of a bad experience with it so I went back with Stila.. I don’t like drugstore eyeliners because one time I tried the Milani eye-tech and it just fades away.

  • Reply
    Ashley Laughlin
    December 18, 2017 at 8:44 pm

    I first found your blog because of this post, and now I’m back here because I’m in need of eyeliner advice.

Leave a Reply